Difficult Vote in Judiciary & Rules Committee

By Rep. Greg Chaney
It was an incredibly difficult vote today in Judiciary & Rules Committee. The bill would have given Juvenile Detention officers, Misdemeanor Probation officers, Juvenile Probation officers, and 911 dispatchers the same accelerated retirement benefit as police and firefighters. H21 would have granted additional benefits to a group of real life heroes who deserve our admiration, appreciation, and who clearly “deserve” to be classified in the same esteem as our law enforcement and firefighter.
However, the specific retirement benefit discussed was created for firefighters and law enforcement specifically in recognition that the physical abilities to do the job are lost at a younger age than other professions. Changing the benefit would shift the basis or standard to apply in an uncertain way, and it would be difficult to figure out just where that line would then lie; it would open to door to additional requests which would be difficult to reject on the basis of any sort of objective standard that would be seen as fair.
To those of you who were affected by today’s vote to hold H21 in committee: Please know, the vote was a difficult judgment on how to manage a standard, not in any way a reflection on the incredibly high esteem in which you are held.

2 thoughts on “Difficult Vote in Judiciary & Rules Committee

  1. I am retired myself, however, have worked in the field of juvenile and adult corrections for 37 years. You fail to mention or recognize in your reference to law enforcement that Idaho Statute includes all probation officers, including those that work for the county, as law enforcement. Failing to pass this bill fails to fix an inequity in the system. This folks have almost identical job descriptions as IDOC probation officers and work sometimes with identical offenders, including offenders who are on the caseloads of both. As an FYI, my life was threatened, as defined by it was serious enough to move my family out of the house, 11 times in my career, all but one were juvenile cases. You should be ashamed.


  2. As a dispatcher who watches the toll the stress our career takes on us physically, I absolutely disagree with this vote. I am brokenhearted and unbelievably disappointed. We have been let down.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s